When Is It Too Late To Plant Oats, Wheat or Barley? Management Considerations for Late-Spring Planted Small Grains in 2023
Margaret A Smith, PhD
Albert Lea Seed Agronomist
Key points are boxed below.
When to Plant Spring-seeded Small Grains
The common guideline for spring planting small grains in the northern U.S. is, “as soon as you can get in the field.” As soon as you can get in the field is earlier than in 2022, but not by much, particularly in northern states.
Long-term average optimum seeding times vary by latitude—earlier farther south and later farther north in the upper Midwest. In most areas, the optimum period spans a 7- to 10-day period. Optimum winter oat and winter wheat planting dates have been defined by several universities, using both research data and field observations. The University of Minnesota suggests these planting date ranges for spring small grains (Table 1).
Table 1 – Optimum seeding dates and last recommended seeding dates for small grains in Minnesota
|Area of Minnesota||Optimum Seeding Date||Last Planting Date|
|South of U.S. Highway 23||First week of April||First week of May|
|South of MN Highway 210||Second week of April||Second week of May|
|South of U.S. Highway 10||Third week of April||Third week of May|
|South of U.S. Highway 2||Fourth week of April||Fourth week of May|
|South of Canadian border||First week of May||First week of June|
Source: University of Minnesota’s Late Planting Spring Small Grains
Other states’ optimal spring-seeeding dates for small grains vary (Table 2).
Table 2 – Recommended spring seeding dates for spring-seeded small grains.
|North Dakota (South)||North Dakota (North)||Nebraska||Ohio||Pennsylvania||New York|
|Before May 15||Before April 30||March 15-April 1||Late March-Early April||April 15-May 10||By April 15|
Key Point: What is Your Optimum Seeding Date Range?
Not sure where you fall in these geographic ranges? The closest you can get to localizing these recommended dates for your farm is to use past experience on the farm and in your surrounding area. Your observations are important due to microclimatic differences, such as in the coulee regions of the Driftless Area in the Upper Midwest and near the Great Lakes.
What is a long term, early average planting day for small grains you or your neighbors grow? Perhaps not the earliest planting date you’ve ever experienced, but early! The optimum for your farm is likely between that date and 7-10 days following. Yields drop fairly consistently after that optimum period for about 30 days, after which small grain yields will likely drop quickly with each day’s additional delay in planting.
This impact on grain development and yield is due largely to temperatures during early development, pollination and grain fill. The ultimate “last planting date” (based on agronomic considerations) for your area will vary from year to year, based on the summer daytime AND nighttime temperatures during grain flowering, pollination and seed fill. The challenge in picking that “last day” is our inability to adequately predict what those temperatures will be.
Growth Stages of Cereal Grains
Spring-planted cereal grains are cool-season annuals that thrive in temperatures below 70 o -75o F. Minimum soil temperatures for germination of small grains are:
- 35 o-37o for spring wheat
- 36o F for barley
- 40o F for oats
Ideally, daytime air temperature highs would reach 60º F and overnight temperatures would not drop below 40º F for a great small grain stand within 8-10 days after planting. Fortunately, small grains are resilient through germination and emergence; during seedling emergence, the plant crown can survive temperatures down to at least 28º F. Oats planted on two farms in northern Iowa in late March this year withstood an extended wet, cold period and didn’t emerge for 30 days, but now have excellent stands.
Cereal grains pass through two development stages: during the first, vegetative stage, leaves, the plant crown, and tillers are initiated and roots begin development. After cereals complete this early growth stage, and sufficiently long days (hours of sunlight per day) and Growing Degree Days (GDD) are accumulated, they enter their second, reproductive stage. To reproduce (produce seed) the plant’s main stem and tillers elongate, plants flower, pollinate and fill seed.
Impacts of Delayed Planting on Cereal Grain Development and Grain Yield and Quality
With delayed planting, average temperatures tend to increase, forcing cereal grain plants to move through their growth stages more quickly—often at the cost of potential yield. While early warmth promotes plant growth, unusually high temperatures can stress the plant. Growing too quickly means that plants produce fewer tillers, develop smaller heads and fewer spikelets per head, have smaller kernels (including more thins), and a lower test weight. In addition, if plants lack adequate moisture in summer heat, they will preserve water by closing their stomata, reducing photosynthesis, which also is detrimental to yield.
Oats in the upper Midwest generally are planted in early April and harvested in mid-July, but the wet, cold spring weather this year has delayed planting. Planting now may push the grain fill stage into the hottest part of the growing season with high temperatures posing a potential threat to grain yield. Several days of temperatures above 75°F during panicle emergence and the milk stage reduces yields. Night temperatures above 70 o F during grain fill in July or August increases plant respiration, which also reduces grain fill.
On average, late-planted cereal grain yields decrease 1 to 1½ percent every day past the optimum planting date. After about 30 days, the rate of decline in yield and test weight accelerates. As grain yields decline, the percent protein in the grain tends to increase. This can be good or bad depending on your market. High protein is desirable for bread wheat, but undesirable for malting barley. For oats, delayed planting also decreases the percentage of plump kernels and increases the incidence of crown rust infection.
Key Point: How Late Can You Still Plant Spring Grains?
Your decision to plant small grains beyond the 30-day extended planting window is based on three major factors, and you may have others:
- The agronomic knowledge about grain yield quality decline. You may be satisfied with a lower grain yield, but food-grade quality will be more difficult to meet. Do you have an alternate market for light-test weight small grains?
- The value of the small grain in 2023. Can you accept lower yields with current small grain prices?
- The importance of small grains in your rotation. Organic growers, in particular, often rely on their small grains in the rotation to prepare for a following corn crop. A legume or mixed cover following the small grain harvest is critical to their corn production. Conventional growers may have more flexibility in their rotation.
Key Point: Planting Oats, Barley, and Wheat Late—Management Options
- You may want to consider an alternative crop instead of risking the probability of a small grain harvest with reduced yield and quality.
- If you do plant late, increase the seeding rate by 1 to 1.5 percent for every day past the optimum planting date up to 1.6-1.8 million seeds per acre. Since tillering will be reduced with warmer temperatures, the increased seeding rate will promote more main stem development to help overcome tillering loss. Even so, summer heat stress is likely to affect final test weight, even in a thickly planted stand.
- If temperatures warm rapidly during seed set and early grain fill and grain yield potential seems poor, consider harvesting your small grain for forage.
Compare this year’s oat planting progress for seven states, below (Table 3). Northern states, Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Michigan are slightly ahead of last year’s oat planting progress, but behind the five-year average percent of oats planted by April 23 or 24. Spring wheat and spring barley planting aren’t currently reported in the USDA-NASS weekly report but likely follow a similar pattern. New York is the exception for areas farther north, with double the percent of oats planted compared to the five-year average. South Dakota oats are behind both 2022 and five-year average planting progress. States farther south, Iowa and Ohio, have had favorable weather and are ahead of both last year and the five-year average oat planting rate.
Table 3 – Percent of the oat crop planted by April 23 and 24, 2023 and comparisons for seven states.
|State||April 23-24, 2023||2022||Five-Year-Average|
Source: UDSA-NASS State Crop Progress Condition Reports
- Can We Predict the Seedling Emergence Time of Spring Wheat?, University of Saskatchewan
- Early Seeding Dates Improve Oat Yield and Quality in the Eastern Prairies, Canadian Journal of Plant Science
- Oats, Purdue University
- Planting Small Grains, University of Minnesota
- Oat Production in Nebraska, University of Nebraska
- Oat Production in North Dakota, North Dakota State University
- Soil Temperatures and Spring Planting Dates, University of Nebraska
- Temperature Thresholds and crop Production: A Review, University of Sydney
- The Development of the Oat Panicle, Illinois Experiment Station
- Tillering in Wheat, Wageningen University
- The Development of the Oat Panicle, Illinois Experiment Station